Tanner Shoes Review: Are These Leather Shoes Worth Your Money?

I know you’re probably scrolling online, looking for your next favorite pair of shoes. Maybe you’ve stumbled across Tanner Shoes and their big promises about quality leather and amazing discounts.

I get it—those ads with the sweet old couple crafting shoes sound tempting! But before you click “buy,” let’s chat about what’s really going on with Tanner Shoes.

I’ve dug into reviews, checked out their website, and gathered all the juicy details to help you decide if these shoes are a steal or a scam. Stick with me—this post has everything you need to know, and I promise it’ll be a fun ride while we figure it out together!

Key Takeaways:

Here’s a quick rundown of what I found out about Tanner Shoes. This list sums up the big points so you can get the gist without digging through everything right away. I’ve bolded the key stuff to make it pop!

• Tanner Shoes markets itself as a small, family-run business. They say Henry and Margaret Tanner craft each pair with love and care. It’s a sweet story that hooks you in!
• Prices are super low compared to normal leather shoes. You’ll see boots drop from $399 to $84. That’s a huge discount, but it raises some eyebrows.
• Many customers complain about quality. People say the shoes aren’t leather—they’re cheap plastic or rubber from China, not handmade in the USA.
• Shipping comes from China, not a cozy workshop. This clashes with their “American-made” vibe and makes folks suspicious.
• Customer service is hard to reach. Lots of reviews mention no replies to emails or calls when things go wrong.
• The website is new—launched late 2024. A fresh site with big claims and no history? That’s a red flag for some.
• Reviews are split. Some rave about comfort, but others scream “scam” louder than a foghorn.
• Big discounts might be a trick. Super cheap prices often mean low quality or fake deals to lure you in.
• No clear return policy. People struggle to get refunds, which isn’t a good sign for a legit company.

This quick list gives you the scoop upfront. Now, let’s dive deeper into each part so you can see the full picture!

What Is Tanner Shoes All About?

Tanner Shoes popped up online with a story that warms your heart. They say Henry and Margaret Tanner started making leather shoes 34 years ago in a small workshop. Each pair supposedly gets crafted by hand with the finest materials.

Their website shows stylish boots and formal shoes at crazy low prices—like $80 for something they claim is worth $400. They even say they’re closing up shop, so it’s your “last chance” to grab a pair.

But here’s the thing: people online aren’t buying it. Many say the story feels fake, like something cooked up to pull you in. The website looks nice, but it’s only been around since December 2024.

That’s pretty new for a company claiming decades of work! I like a good deal as much as anyone, but this setup makes me wonder what’s really going on behind the scenes.

The Tanner Shoes Website Experience

Visiting tannershoes.com feels smooth at first. The site has clean pictures of shoes and a simple layout. You see options like “Richard Chelsea Boots” or “Mason Formal Shoes” with big “sale” tags.

Free shipping pops up too, which sounds awesome. But dig a little deeper, and things get shaky. There’s no phone number to call—just an email that some folks say never gets a reply.

I noticed the “About Us” page repeats the same Henry and Margaret story over and over. It’s sweet, but it lacks details. Where’s this workshop? How do they make the shoes?

Plus, the domain being so new doesn’t match their 34-year tale. It’s like they want you to feel good about buying without proving much. For a site pushing a closing sale, it’s odd they don’t share more!

What Customers Say About Tanner Shoes

Customer reviews tell a wild story. On Trustpilot, some give Tanner Shoes five stars, saying the shoes fit great and look amazing. “Best shoes I’ve ever bought!” one person wrote.

But then you’ve got a flood of one-star rants. People call the shoes “cheap Chinese junk” and say they fall apart fast. “I got plastic, not leather!” is a common complaint.

The split is crazy—either folks love them or hate them with a passion. Some say shipping took weeks, and the box came from China, not a family workshop.

Others mention sizing issues, like getting a US 8 when they ordered a 10. It’s a mixed bag, and that makes it tough to trust what you’re really getting.

Are Tanner Shoes Really Handmade?

Here’s where it gets messy. Tanner Shoes says every pair is handmade with top-notch leather. But tons of buyers disagree. They say the shoes feel like rubber or plastic, not the fancy leather promised.

“These aren’t handmade—they’re mass-produced garbage!” one review shouted. Another person said the stitching looked sloppy, like it came off a factory line.

The shipping from China adds fuel to the fire. If Henry and Margaret are crafting these in a little US workshop, why’s the package coming from halfway around the world?

It’s hard to believe the handmade story when the evidence points to something else. I wanted to root for them, but this part smells fishy!

Pricing: Too Good to Be True?

Let’s talk money. Tanner Shoes lists boots at $399, then slashes them to $84. Formal shoes drop from $349 to $79. That’s a huge cut—like 75% off or more! I love a bargain, but this feels off. Real leather shoes from legit brands don’t dip that low unless something’s up.

Online chatter says these prices are a bait-and-switch trick. You think you’re getting premium stuff cheap, but you end up with junk worth less than you paid. “Don’t fall for the glossy photos!” one buyer warned. Discounts this big usually mean corners got cut somewhere—probably on quality. It’s tempting, but I’d think twice before jumping in.

Shipping and Delivery Details

Shipping is a big deal with Tanner Shoes, and not in a good way. They promise free standard shipping, which sounds nice. But reviews say it takes forever—sometimes two weeks or more. Worse, the packages come from China, not a US workshop. “I waited ages for shoes that weren’t even from America!” one person griped.

Tracking is spotty too. Some folks got no updates until the shoes just showed up—or didn’t. A few even said their orders vanished, with no word from customer service. For a company saying they’re closing down, you’d think they’d hustle to get shoes out fast. This slow, overseas shipping vibe doesn’t match their story.

Quality of Tanner Shoes Products

Quality is the make-or-break factor, right? Tanner Shoes says you’re getting durable, comfy leather shoes. Some buyers agree, saying they’re “super comfortable” and look sharp. But way more call it a letdown. “They fell apart in a week!” one review said. Others got shoes that smelled like chemicals or had soles that peeled off.

The “leather” debate is huge. Most say it’s fake—plastic or rubber pretending to be the real deal. “Walmart shoes are better than this!” someone joked. For a brand banking on craftsmanship, the quality complaints hit hard. It’s a gamble—some get lucky, but most feel cheated.

Customer Service: Help or Headache?

Good customer service can save a shaky product, but Tanner Shoes struggles here. Their site lists support@tannershoes.com as the contact. Sounds easy, right? Nope. People say emails go unanswered, and there’s no phone number to call. “They ghosted me when I asked for a refund!” one buyer fumed.

Returns sound like a nightmare too. Some got offered 20% back but had to ship to China—at their own cost! For a “closing” business, they’re not making it easy to fix2019 fix this. I’d love to see them step up here, but right now, it’s a weak spot.

Is Tanner Shoes a Scam?

Okay, let’s tackle the big question: Is Tanner Shoes legit or a scam? The signs aren’t great. New website, fake leather claims, China shipping, and awful customer service?

That’s a scam recipe. Tons of reviews call it out—“100% a scam!” one said. The low prices and sob story seem designed to hook you.

But some folks did get shoes and liked them, so it’s not a total ghost operation. Maybe it’s more of a shady bait-and-switch than a full-on scam. Either way, the trust is shaky. I wouldn’t risk it unless you’re cool with rolling the dice on what shows up—or doesn’t.

Comparing Tanner Shoes to Other Brands

How does Tanner stack up? Take Born Shoes—they’ve got a “Tanner” loafer that’s lightweight and comfy, with solid reviews. Or Allen Edmonds’ “Tanner Chelsea Boot”—premium suede, built to last. Both cost more (around $150-$300), but you get real quality and a legit reputation.

Tanner Shoes’ $80 price tag looks tempting next to those, but the quality gap is huge. “You get what you pay for,” as my mom always says. If you want leather that lasts, skip Tanner and save up for a trusted brand. The discount’s not worth the headache if it’s junk.

Should You Buy Tanner Shoes?

So, should you buy from Tanner Shoes? I’d say pass. The red flags—new site, fake leather, bad service—outweigh the few happy reviews. “Don’t be a victim!” one reviewer begged, and I agree. You might score a decent pair, but it’s a long shot.

If you’re set on trying them, use a credit card for protection and keep expectations low. Me? I’d rather spend a bit more for shoes I know won’t fall apart. Tanner Shoes sounds like a sweet deal, but it’s probably more trouble than it’s worth. Your feet deserve better!

FAQs

Is Tanner Shoes a real company?

Tanner Shoes exists as an online store, but its claims are shaky. They say Henry and Margaret Tanner run it with 34 years of experience, yet the website’s new and shipping’s from China. It’s real, but likely not what they promise.

Are Tanner Shoes good quality?

Some say yes, but most say no. Reviews slam the shoes as cheap plastic or rubber, not leather. Quality seems hit-or-miss—don’t expect much for the price.

Where are Tanner Shoes made?

They claim the USA, but packages ship from China. That mismatch suggests they’re mass-produced overseas, not handmade here.

Can I return Tanner Shoes if I don’t like them?

It’s tough. Customer service is hard to reach, and returns might mean shipping to China at your expense. Check their site, but don’t count on an easy refund.

Why are Tanner Shoes so cheap?

Big discounts (like $399 to $84) are their hook. It’s likely a trick to sell low-quality stuff at a “deal” price, not a real sale.